| Play | The Crucible |
| Musical | Wonderful Town |
| Actor—Play | Tom Ewell, The Seven Year Itch |
| Actress—Play | Shirley Booth, Time of the Cuckoo |
| Supporting or Featured Actor—Play | John Williams, Dial M for Murder |
| Supporting or Featured Actress—Play | Beatrice Straight, The Crucible |
| Actor—Musical | Thomas Mitchell, Hazel Flagg |
| Actress—Musical | Rosalind Russell, Wonderful Town |
| Supporting or Featured Actor—Musical | Hiram Sherman, Two's Company |
| Supporting or Featured Actress—Musical | Sheila Bond, Wish You Were Here |
| Author—Play | Arthur Miller, The Crucible |
| Authors—Musical | Joseph Fields and Jerome Chodorov, Wonderful Town |
| Director | Joshua Logan, Picnic |
| Producer—Play | Kermit Bloomgarden, The Crucible |
| Producer—Musical | Robert Fryer, Wonderful Town |
| Composer | Leonard Bernstein, Wonderful Town |
| Scenic Designer | Raoul Pène Du Bois, Wonderful Town |
| Costume Designer | Miles White, Hazel Flagg |
| Choreographer | Donald Saddler, Wonderful Town |
| Conductor and Musical Director | Lehman Engel, Wonderful Town and Gilbert and Sullivan season |
| Stage Technician | Abe Kurnit, Wish You Were Here |
| Special Awards | Beatrice Lillie |
| Danny Kaye |
| Equity Community Theatre |
Information Please® Database, © 2007 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.