| Play | Becket, Jean Anouilh |
| Musical | Bye, Bye Birdie |
| Actor—Play | Zero Mostel, Rhinoceros |
| Actress—Play | Joan Plowright, A Taste of Honey |
| Supporting or Featured Actor—Play | Martin Gabel, Big Fish, Little Fish |
| Supporting or Featured Actress—Play | Colleen Dewhurst, All the Way Home |
 Richard Burton, Camelot Archive Photos |
Actor—Musical | Richard Burton, Camelot |
| Actress—Musical | Elizabeth Seal, Irma la Douce |
| Supporting or Featured Actor—Musical | Dick Van Dyke, Bye, Bye Birdie |
| Supporting or Featured Actress—Musical | Tammy Grimes, The Unsinkable Molly Brown |
| Author—Play | Jean Anouilh, Becket |
| Author—Musical | Michael Stewart, Bye, Bye Birdie |
| Director—Play | Sir John Gielgud, Big Fish, Little Fish |
| Director—Musical | Gower Champion, Bye, Bye Birdie |
| Producer—Play | David Merrick, Becket |
| Producer—Musical | Edward Padula, Bye, Bye Birdie |
| Scenic Designer—Play | Oliver Smith, Becket |
| Scenic Designer—Musical | Oliver Smith, Camelot |
| Costume Designer—Play | Motley, Becket |
| Costume Designers—Musical | Adrian and Tony Duquette, Camelot |
| Choreographer | Gower Champion, Bye, Bye Birdie |
| Conductor and Musical Director | Franz Allers, Camelot |
| Stage Technician | Teddy Van Bemmel, Becket |
| Special Awards | David Merrick |
| The Theatre Guild |
Cite